History of the human sciences the controversy over. Critical theory between pollocks state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason. In this chapter we shall identify the essential features of capital ism and then go on to discuss state capitalism and the nature of the. The impact of friedrich pollocks state capitalism concept. The frank, limitless enthusiasm which the thirtytwoyearold friedrich pollock had for karl marx was somewhat artless, although it did have its own appeal. The importance of state capitalism and world revolu tion, published in 1950, was that it not only projected a theory of state capitalism, but at its very beginning it stated definitely and unequivocally that trotskys whole method of analysis and results were to be repudiated. Critical theory between pollock s state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason. In the other, socialism, the state owns the means of production, and stateowned enterprises seek to maximize social good rather than profits. The controversy over friedrich pollocks state capitalism.
Pollocks thesis of state capitalism, and claimed that capitalisms contradictions remained operative in germany even if covered up by the bureaucratic apparatus and the ideology of the volk community b 2278. These are the sources and citations used to research state capitalism. In his lecture pollock lays out a new concept of a political antisemitism that he distinguishes not only from premodern christian antijudaism but also from nineteenthcentury racialist discourse. Though critical theory has often been heralded or criticized and rejected as a reformulation of marxian theory for our times, its relation with the critique of political economy, and in particular the economic treatises, has barely been studied. Stateowned enterprises soes monopolize key industries. Economic history, historical analysis, and the new history of capitalism eric hilt department of economics. Sovereign wealth funds, a recently coined term for stateowned investment portfolios, account.
Its possibilities and limitations, in andrew arato and eike gebhardt, eds, the essential frankfurt school reader, london 1982, pp. Neumann disagreed with friedrich pollocks assessment that nazism was a new order of state capitalism that had replaced monopoly capitalism. The neumannpollock debate in light of herbert marcuses state and individual under national socialism. Friedrich pollock rolf wiggerhaus the frankfurt school munich, 1986 1995. Request pdf on sep 1, 2015, tobias ten brink and others published economic analysis in critical theory. Indeed, neumann claimed, the very notion of state capitalism is a contradiction in terms. Pollock s jewishborn father turned away from judaism, and raised his son accordingly. Marxian critique of capitalism and the theory of revolution in order to confront those new social and political conditions which had evolved since marxs death. The term state capitalism is frequently used in two different ways. Pollocks own study ofsovietplanning, keynesian theory. Introduction friedrich pollock and the primacy of the.
Nancy fraser, feminism, capitalism and the cunning of. The controversy over state capitalism had both theoretical and practical significance. The impact of friedrich pollock s state capitalism concept. This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on sunday, april 12, 2020. October 2012 abstract this paper documents a hallmark feature of chinas state capitalism as the state controlling the economy in a vertical structure. During this time he met max horkheimer, with whom he became a lifelong friend. The vitality of critical theory current perspectives in social theory, vol. It should not go unnoticed that american labor was the main target of frankfurt school inquiry in the united states at the moment the fas10. Gebhardt eds, the essential frankfurt school reader oxford. Article information, pdf download for the controversy over friedrich.
Friedrich pollock was born to a leather factory owner in freiburg im breisgau. The start of the twentyfirst century is a good time to reevaluate longheld. The critique of capitalism is the bedrock on which rests the reputation of frankfurt school critical theory. The rise of state capitalism as the cold war stumbled to a close, the belief that governments could micromanage national economies and generate prosperity seemed dead. Introduction friedrich pollock and the primacy of the political. Though critical theory has often been heralded or criticized. It also preserves it and raises it to a higher level. But i see no reason not to extend this observation to the institutes work during the 1950s. To say that state capitalism is a variety of capitalism may be a tautology, but it brings out the need to be clear on what capitalism is before embarking on any discussion of what state capitalism might be. Friedrich pollocks state capitalism manfred gangl university of applied studies, germany abstract the critique of capitalism is the bedrock on which rests the reputation of frankfurt school critical theory.
The federal mail system or a stateowned railway are examples of this kind of state capitalism. A model of chinas state capitalism xi li xuewen liu yong wang the hong kong university of science and technology this version. Simply put, with his state capitalism thesis, friedrich pollock alleged that the command and mixed economies of the 1920s and 1930s marked the. In the other, socialism, the state owns the means of production, and state owned enterprises seek to maximize social good rather than profits. In state capitalism, the liberal separation of the political and economic spheres is done away with. Copynohted material vi contents 119 128 6 145 155 172 184 199 2 219 233 247 255 8 9.
Incubation of the economic crisis in postcolonial cameroon. Marxian economics and the great depression springerlink. Although there may be some truth in that view, i will follow the more conventional path of excluding the region from this first moment of my story, in part because it was not until after 1989 that secondwave feminism. Critical theory between pollocks state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason, dahms, h. It is a dialectical transformation of state capitalism, not a cancellation of it. State capitalism its possibilities and limitations. Even as state capitalism has risen, some writers, business leaders, and politicians contend that such systems fail to encourage innovation, the key to longterm growth and economic wealth. Its possibilities and limitations 1990 the continuum publishing company new york. Trans state capitalism does not simply negate state capital. The theory of capitalism in the german economic tradition. Pollock, state capitalism the reputation of frankfurt school critical theory rests upon its critique of capitalism. Such implication of the state in economic affairs is essentially state capitalism that pollock considers as a social and economic governing order differing on two variants. The neumann pollock debate in light of herbert marcuses state and individual under national socialism.
According to pollock, the monopoly economy that followed the free market system of the 19th century was gradually transforming into state capitalism, con. And it can make life very difficult for all sections of the ruling class. State capitalism is an economic system in which the state undertakes commercial i. It has often been heralded or criticized and rejected as a reformulation of marxian theory for our times. Pollock thought that relatively little work had been devoted to understanding the democratic form of state capitalism. Its possibilities and limitations, as well as his consideration of the question is national socialism a new order. Other companies owned by or aligned with the state enjoy growing market power in major economic sectors in the worlds fastestgrowing economies. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. State capitalism is the authoritarian state of the present. King introduction the aim of this paper is to explore the reactions to the bolshevik revolution of one group of critics from the left. Critical theory between pollock s state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason, in koslowski, p. The state and capitalism today international socialism. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing.
The controversy over friedrich pollocks state capitalism manfred. Its possibilities and limitations, in andrew, arato and eike. Chapter 1 the early frankfurt school critique of capitalism. Its possibilities and limitations frederick pollock. Economic history, historical analysis, and the new.
State capitalism and dictatorship marxists internet archive. The selfmovement of the concept of the commodity leads to the concept of state capitalism horkheimer 1940, 96, 108. Critical theory between pollocks state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason, in koslowski, p. American capitalism by berle and means as far back as 1932. And, in the twentieth century, there is a backlash against the new deal and the welfare state, and the rise.
Yet the relation between critical theory and the critique of political. The dynamism and market power of japan, the united states, and western europefueled by private wealth, private investment, and private enterpriseappeared to have fully and. Pollocks state capitalism and the critique of instrumental reason. The increasingly transparent weaknesses and contradictions in the capitalist system may eventually convince even some of its more uncritical supporters that an alternative needs to be found. Although some form of capitalism is the basis for nearly all economies today, for much of the last century it was but one of two major approaches to economic organization. Natural and other noneconomic lfmitadojw9 i to be fully workable, state capitalism needs an adequate supply of raw material, plant and labor of all kinds technicians, administrators, skilled and unskilled labor, characteristic for a highly industrialized country. Sovereign wealth funds, a recently coined term for state owned investment portfolios, account for oneeighth of global investment. The origin of capitalism the damage, as many millions of people have often suffered from the cure as from the disease. The impact of friedrich pollock s state capitalism concept find, read and cite all the. Its possibilities and limitations free download as pdf file. In the process a critical theory of society emerged to deal with those aspects of social reality which marx and his orthodox followers neglected or downplayed.
361 1489 1399 185 1584 1569 692 221 685 710 1019 17 593 1385 1349 261 844 1172 1353 1461 1409 1537 747 28 564 294 259 1032 1359 930 423